Skip to Main Content
md-user
5-minute read

Public liability and professional indemnity insurance differences explained

A freelancer sat at her desk working from her iPad.

Professional indemnity insurance (PI) and public liability insurance (PL) are different types of business insurance that cover compensation claims. It is often misunderstood how each of these business insurance policies protect businesses against risk.

So what is the difference between public liability and professional indemnity insurance? The short answer is: professional indemnity insurance covers claims made by clients for professional negligence or mistakes, whereas public liability insurance covers claims made by members of the public for injury or damage.

Read on to discover how each of these two important business insurance policies help organisations of all sizes, and why it’s important and cost-effective to consider purchasing both policies.

Key differences between public liability & professional indemnity

Here are some examples that help to make the differences between professional indemnity and public liability insurance a little clearer.

   Public liability insurance  Professional indemnity insurance
What it covers Claims from third parties for injury or property damage caused by your business activities Claims from clients alleging your professional advice, services, or work caused them financial loss
Who makes the  claim A member of the public, customer, or third party A client or former client
Type of harm covered Physical injury or damage to property Financial loss, reputational damage, or consequential losses arising from professional error
Typical example A client trips over a cable at your office and injures themselves A client alleges that incorrect advice you gave led to a costly business decision
Legal  requirement  No (except where contractually required) No (except where contractually required)
Who needs it  most Any business that interacts with the public or clients face to face  Any business that provides professional advice, consultancy, or specialist services
Cover limits (Markel Direct) £1 million to £5 million £50,000 to £5 million

Is professional indemnity the same as public liability?

No. Professional indemnity insurance is not the same as public liability insurance, and the two are often confused. While both fall under the umbrella of business insurance and both respond to claims made against your business, they protect you against fundamentally different types of risk.

 

What is public liability insurance?

It can help to cover your business if a member of the public, a customer, or a third party is physically injured or has their property damaged because of your business activities.

What is professional indemnity insurance?

In both cases, the claimant is different, the type of harm is different, and the circumstances that trigger a claim are different. Professional indemnity vs public liability is not a question of one being better than the other, as they serve distinct purposes and, for many businesses, both may be seen as necessary. 

 

How does public liability (PL) insurance work?

Public liability insurance helps cover against the costs associated with claims of injury or property damage by a member of the public against your business. This could include customers, clients, suppliers or passers-by.

Public liability insurance can also cover the cost of your legal defence, compensation payments, medical costs and loss of income as a result of the claim.

Large organisations carry public liability insurance as good practice because they typically deal with the general public on a daily basis, but many freelancers may not be aware of the need to carry this type of insurance which can leave them exposed to potential financially damaging claims.

Freelancers who meet clients in their own homes, or who meet clients at their client’s premises may wish to consider public liability insurance in case the worst should happen. It is easy to think you are careful and conscientious, but many accidents happen due to something that is out of our control. Examples of accidental damage caused to client property by freelancers are not uncommon, but without public liability insurance in place they can be costly.

For contractors the decision is typically easier as many contracts will stipulate both professional indemnity insurance and public liability insurance as mandatory in the terms of their contract.

PL insurance claims can be wide ranging, the most common examples demonstrate how PL insurance works and include the following:

  • Slips - a customer visits your workplace and slips on wet floor, breaking their arm. As a result they cannot work and claim against you for the financial loss suffered.
    Trips - a client trips over a loose wire and sprains their wrist. They make a compensation claim against you.
    Falls - a client falls down some stairs and breaks and ankle. They claim against you for the time they are off work and for rehabilitation costs.

Click here for further information about liability insurance.

Click here for a quick online quote for public liability insurance.

 

Do I need both professional indemnity and public liability insurance?

For many businesses, yes – but this depends on individual circumstances and needs. Understanding why requires thinking about the two different directions a claim can come from.

Public liability and professional indemnity insurance protect against different types of risk, and most businesses face both. Consider a management consultant who meets clients at their office: if a client trips on a loose rug and injures themselves, that's a public liability claim. If the same consultant provides strategic advice that leads to a costly business decision that loses the client money, that's a professional indemnity claim. One policy alone may leave them exposed on the other front.

The same logic applies across a huge range of professions. An IT contractor who visits client sites needs public liability insurance in case they accidentally damage equipment or injure someone, and professional indemnity insurance in case a system they implement fails and causes operational disruption. A marketing consultant presenting at a client's offices needs both for precisely the same reasons.

The question of whether you need both professional indemnity and public liability insurance ultimately comes down to your specific business activities and risk acceptance, but if you provide professional services and interact with clients or the public in person, carrying professional indemnity and public liability insurance together is arguably considered to be the prudent choice. At Markel Direct, both covers can be arranged as part of a single, tailored policy, making it straightforward to ensure you're protected on both counts.

*Price based on an IT contractor requiring £50,000 of professional indemnity insurance.

 
  • Professionals
  • Trades
  • Charities, community and clubs